How does a 1031 Exchange Work in Eminent Domain? (I.R.C. § 1033)

Underwood Law Firm, P.C.
Aerial view of land as a background image with texts about eminent domain

As if eminent domain is not bad enough, after you’ve gone through the process, the government wants to tax you on the land it made you sell. Savvy property owners, however, can limit their tax liabilities through the use of a 1031 exchange process.

Can a property owner limit the effects of eminent domain?

Internal Revenue Code section 1033 permits the owner of property taken by eminent domain to avoid income tax liability by purchasing qualified replacement property within a specified time following the condemnation.

This means that the recognition of any gain realized in connection with the amount paid for the condemned property is deferred to a later time.

Effectively, the “cost basis” of the property taken through eminent domain is transferred to the replacement property, and the gain is recognized only at a later time as the replacement property is sold or transferred.

Additionally, when that property owner dies, and the heirs take the property, there may never be any recognition of any gain.

What Is the Timeline to Buy Replacement Property for an Eminent Domain 1031 Exchange?

To qualify, however, the owner must acquire the replacement property relatively quickly.

Notably, the replacement period begins as soon as the property owner has a right to all or part of the condemnation award, and the replacement period continues to run during litigation regarding compensation. (see I.R.C. § 1033(a)(2).)

Otherwise, the replacement period begins on the date that the property is first threatened with condemnation and ends three years after the end of the first tax year in which any gain is realized. (see I.R.C. § 1033(g).)

Interestingly, the property owner can use the money from the condemned property for more than one replacement property. (see Rev. Rul. 58-396, 1958-2 C.B. 403.)

Conversely, a property owner who loses two properties to an eminent domain can replace them with just one qualified piece of real estate. (Masser v. C.I.R. (T.C. 1958) 30 T.C. 741, 746-747.)

What Qualifies as Replacement Property for an Eminent Domain 1031 Exchange?

One limitation, however, is that the new property purchased with the money from the property taken by eminent domain must “qualify” as replacement property.

The two tests are the “like-kind” test and the “similar service” test. When the taken property is used for business or as an investment, then the “like-kind” test applies. (See I.R.C. § 1033(g)(1).)

When the taken property is used for personal purposes, then the “similar service” test applies. (see I.R.C. § 1033(a).)

Conclusion

The 1031 Exchange can be a powerful tool in eminent domain to limit the tax consequences from the government’s taking of private property. In order to take advantage of it, however, the property owner should seek counsel about the best ways to do so.

If you are faced with an eminent domain proceeding and would like assistance navigating the process, please contact Underwood Law Firm, P.C. for an initial consultation.

Go here to get more details.

Client Reviews

We were in need of a real estate attorney. Eli Underwood provided excellent legal advice and services. He explained everything well and followed through with all important issues that needed attention. We found him to be reliable, courteous, patient and extremely professional. We highly recommend...

I.S.

I own a real estate investment company that operates across multiple states (California, Washington, Oregon, Montana, and more), whenever I run into an issue that needs legal attention, Eli is my first call. I've been working with him for years. He is an amazing attorney and I highly recommend him."...

T.W.

Mr. Underwood is a fantastic Lawyer with extraordinary ethics. He responds quickly, which is rare these days, and he is very knowledgeable in his craft. It was a pleasure working with him and we will definitely use his services in the future if needed. Thank you for your help Sir!

M.O.

Eli took our case and controlled every hurdle put before us. I one time commented to him that he must love his job because it seemed that he was always available. When talking about my case to anyone I always bring up where, I believe, the other parties Lawyer tried to take advantage of my wife and...

E.T

We were in need of an attorney with considerable knowledge of real estate law and the legal issues related to property ownership. Eli Underwood went above and beyond our expectations. In keeping us abreast of our suit, his communication skills were outstanding. This talent was especially...

P.B.

In our need for legal services we found Eli to be well informed and on top of our case and our needs. Our's was not an ordinary case as it was a case with many facets. It was a very convoluted case. There were multiple owners involved in a property dispute where one of the owners sued the rest of...

M.A.